
Sindhi Dal Pakwan
Sindhi dal pakwan is a spiced chana dal curry served with crisp deep-fried flatbreads. The dal is tangy from tamarind and lime, warmly spiced, and finished with raw onion and coriander.
Dal cooking spice
1.5 gAdded to the dal with salt and water (step 2)Ground spices for the dal
6 gStirred into the onion and tomato (step 5)Pakwan spices
1.7 gMixed into the flour for the pakwan (step 8)Everything else
Method
- Rinse 200 g chana dal and soak in plenty of water for 2 hours, then drain.
- Boil the dal with the dal cooking spice, salt and enough water to cover until soft but not mushy, 30–35 minutes.
- Heat 27 g vegetable oil in a pan over medium heat. Add 300 g onion and 4 g green bird’s eye chilli and fry until the onion is golden.
- Add 120 g tomato and cook until softened, about 5 minutes.
- Add the ground spices for the dal and stir for 1 minute.
- Add the cooked dal, 12 g tamarind paste and a splash of water. Simmer for 10 minutes, stirring now and then.
- Check the salt, then scatter over 150 g red onion and 3 g coriander leaves and squeeze over 50 g lime juice.
- Mix 300 g plain flour, the pakwan spices and salt in a bowl.
- Rub in 14.1 g melted butter, then add water a little at a time to make a stiff dough.
- Rest the dough for 20 minutes, then divide into 12–15 balls and roll each into a thin disc; prick all over with a fork.
- Heat enough oil for deep-frying to 170°C (340°F). Fry the discs, a few at a time, until golden and crisp, 1–2 minutes per side; drain on kitchen paper.
- Serve the dal with the pakwan.
Don't have something?

Chana dal

Yellow split peasUse 100% of the weight. Soak for at least 1 hour; takes about 10 minutes longer to cook through and has a marginally earthier flavour.
Pigeon peasUse 100% of the weight. Reduces cooking time by about 10 minutes and breaks down softer, giving a smoother consistency rather than distinct grains.
Black gramFor tempering or tadka only: use 70% of the weight. Browns faster in hot oil, providing a nutty, crunchy bite.

Ground turmeric

Ground gingerUse 50% of the weight. Mimics turmeric's warm, earthy, rhizome background, but provides none of the golden-yellow colour.
SaffronSteep a tiny pinch (0.1 g per 2 g turmeric) in 2 tbsp warm water; use to match the rich golden hue. Contributes an aristocratic, honeyed floral flavour rather than earthy bitterness.

Vegetable oil

Peanut oilUse 1:1 by weight. Handles high-heat frying identically and introduces a very subtle, pleasant nuttiness.
GheeUse 1:1 by weight. Yields a much richer, authentic aroma and a glossy, heavier mouthfeel.
Mustard oilUse 1:1 by weight. Heat until smoking, then cool slightly before cooking to temper its intensely pungent, sharp mustard kick.

Onion


Green bird's eye chilli

Bird's eye green chilliUse the same weight; heat and flavour are very close.
Green chilliUse 1.5 to 2 times the weight; deseed for less heat. Larger chillies are more watery.
Fresh green chilliUse 1.5 to 2 times the weight; chop finely and adjust heat by tasting.

Tomato

Tomato puréeUse 40% to 50% of the fresh tomato weight mixed with a splash of water. Imparts a deeper red colour, thicker sauce, and slightly sweeter cooked flavour.
Plain yogurtUse 60% of the weight, whisked smooth and added on low heat. Provides rich body and sourness, though the gravy becomes paler and creamier.

Ground cumin

Cumin seedDry-roast briefly and grind finely; use equal weight (1:1). Imparts an even punchier, nuttier, toasty aroma than pre-ground cumin.
Ground corianderUse equal weight (1:1). Adds mild, lemony sweetness rather than cumin's smoky, earthy bite; curries will taste lighter and less savoury.
Black cumin seedsGrind finely; use 60% to 75% of the weight. Produces a darker, more complex, smoky-herbal flavour suited to rich gravies.

Ground coriander

Coriander seedsDry-roast lightly in a pan and grind to a fine powder; use equal weight (1:1). Offers a noticeably fresher, brighter citrus note.
Ground cuminUse 50% to 75% of the weight. Lacks the floral, citrusy profile of coriander and turns the gravy heavier, earthier, and darker.
Garam masalaUse 50% of the weight and stir in near the end of cooking. Adds warmth and depth since it contains ground coriander, but introduces stronger spices like clove and cinnamon.

Kashmiri chilli powder

Dried kashmiri chilliGrind deseeded dried pods to an equal weight of powder; gives identical vivid red colour and gentle warmth.
Red chilli powderUse 25% of the weight mixed with sweet paprika for colour; straight red chilli powder is substantially hotter and will make the dish fiery.
Chilli powderUse one-third of the weight; the sauce will be less intensely red and notably sharper in heat.

Garam masala

Ground cuminUse 50% of the weight mixed with equal parts ground coriander and a pinch of ground cinnamon, ground cloves, and ground green cardamom. Sprinkle near the end for a warming finish.
Lentil stew spice mixUse 75% of the weight. Simmer briefly in the gravy; imparts roasted warmth and complexity, though it adds a slight tang and earthy lentil undertone.

Tamarind paste

Tamarind pulpUse 120–150% of the weight and strain; pulp is less concentrated, so simmer a little longer to thicken.
Tamarind extractUse 150–200% of the weight and reduce gently; extract is already diluted.
Lime juiceUse 60–70% of the weight with a pinch of jaggery; sharper, so add near the end off the heat.

Amchoor

Lemon juiceUse 15 g (1 tbsp) for every 5 g of amchoor. Stir in at the very end off the heat; adds liquid and fresh citrus aroma rather than dry fruity tang.
Tamarind extractUse 75% of the weight, dissolved in a splash of warm water. Simmer briefly; darkens the gravy and provides a deeper, caramelised sourness.

Coriander leaves

Coriander (cilantro) or basilUse the same weight, choosing the coriander element if available. If only basil is available, expect a sweeter, more aniseed flavour.
Basil leavesUse the same weight. Basil is sweeter and more aromatic in a different way; add near the end so it keeps its perfume.
Coriander pasteUse 1.5 times the weight and reduce other liquid slightly; it is less fresh and more concentrated, so taste before adding more.

Red onion

OnionUse the same weight; cook a little longer. Milder and less sweet when raw.
ShallotUse the same weight; sweeter and softer, so reduce cooking time slightly.
Spring onionUse only the white parts, weight for weight, for raw or quick-cooked dishes; green parts are too grassy for long cooking.

Lime

LemonUse the same weight; sharper and less floral, so reduce any extra souring slightly.
Lemon juiceUse about 30 g juice per lime (2 tbsp), strain pips; add at the end for fresh sourness.
Dried mango powderUse 1 g amchoor for about 15 g lime juice; add early with spices; gives dry mango sourness, not citrus aroma.

Plain flour

Whole wheat flourUse the same weight, add 10–15% more water and rest the dough for 20 minutes; the result is heavier and nuttier.
Rice flourUse the same weight for crisp coatings; for doughs use no more than half rice flour with wheat flour, or it will be crumbly.
CornflourFor thickening use half the weight, mixed with cold water; it is not suitable for bread or chapati dough.

Cumin seed

Ground cuminUse 70% of the weight; add with ground spices or sauce bases rather than hot oil tempering, where it scorches quickly and turns bitter.
Black cumin seedsUse equal weight for oil tempering. Delivers an earthy profile with an additional musky, smoky, and slightly bitter edge.
Fennel seedUse 60% of the weight for tempering; offers comparable warm aroma, but leans sweet and liquorice-like rather than savoury and earthy.

Paprika

Kashmiri red chilli powderUse the same weight for a similar mild colour; it has a little more heat, so taste as you go.
Red chilli powderUse 50–60% of the weight; it is much hotter, so add it gradually.
Cayenne pepperUse 25–40% of the weight; it gives heat but little colour, so it changes the look of the dish.

Butter

Unsalted butterUse 100% of the weight. If the original recipe relies on salted table butter, add a pinch of salt to balance.
GheeUse 80% to 85% of the weight. Ghee is pure butterfat with moisture removed; it yields a deeper, nuttier flavour and handles high heat better.
Vegetable oilUse 80% of the weight for frying or tempering. The dish loses sweet dairy richness but remains glossy and light.

Oil

Vegetable oilUse the same weight. It is neutral and behaves the same in frying and tempering; no noticeable change in flavour.
Corn or vegetable oilUse the same weight. Neutral and good for high heat; the dish will taste virtually the same.
Groundnut oilUse the same weight. It has a mild nutty flavour and is good for Indian cooking; heat until just hot, not smoking, so the nuttiness does not dominate.
Similar dishes

- Same: Dal Dhokli and this dish are both lentil curries soured with tamarind and seasoned with green chilli, onion, cumin, turmeric and Kashmiri chilli.
- Different: Dal Dhokli uses toor dal, jaggery, mustard seed, clove, cassia, asafoetida, curry leaf, ginger and simmered wheat-and-gram-flour strips, while this dish uses chana dal, amchoor, lime and separate deep-fried plain-flour pakwan.

- Same: Both are chana dal curries with turmeric, vegetable oil, cumin, Kashmiri chilli powder, tomato, onion, coriander and salt.
- Different: Tadka Dal uses more water plus garlic, ginger and fennel seed, and it has no tamarind, lime, amchoor, green bird’s eye chilli, red onion garnish or deep-fried flatbread; this dish is sourer and is served with pakwan made from plain flour, butter, cumin seed and paprika.

- Same: Dal Makhani shares with this dish a dal base cooked with onion, tomato, cumin, coriander, Kashmiri chilli and green chilli.
- Different: Dal Makhani uses urad dal and adds double cream, butter, ghee, asafoetida and ginger garlic paste, but it lacks this dish’s tamarind, lime, amchoor, raw onion-coriander finish and deep-fried flatbread.

- Same: Punjabi Langarwalli Dal shares with this dish a split-legume base and a masala of turmeric, tomato, green chilli, Kashmiri chilli powder, garam masala and cumin.
- Different: Punjabi Langarwalli Dal uses split urad dal and ghee with asafoetida, ginger and a cumin–dried red chilli tadka, while this dish uses chana dal, vegetable oil, onion, tamarind, amchoor and lime and is served with deep-fried flour flatbread.







































